Swiss Intelligence Oversight Body Cites Problems with Database

Earlier this month, Swiss media announced that the oversight body for Swiss intelligence and national security activities, the “Geschäftsprüfungsdelegation” (GPDel), had produced a negative report on the state of the Federal Intelligence Service’s information system, the ISIS-NT. According to the report, the database held entries on 50,000 people in 2001 and grew to 60,000 entries in 2004 (p. 6). Since that time, however, the database has grown to contain primary entries on 120,000 individuals plus an additional 80,000 or so “third persons”. These third persons represent individuals who have some tie to the 120,000 individuals of primary concern or to some event recorded in the database.

The GPDel expressed concern about the overall quality of the data held in the database. Based on its inspection of various sample entries, the GPDel found instances where the individuals or incidents entered into the database were not serious enough to warrant inclusion as well as instances where data had expired but had not been deleted. The GPDel also opined that the database suffered from the systematic entry of incorrect data due to a flaw in internal entry guidelines. Additionally, it suspected that many of the 80,000 third person entries did not meet the legal requirements that warranted entry in the database.

According to an article in the Neue Zürcher Zeitung, only about 5% of the entries concern Swiss citizens and only 12.2% are Swiss residents. These facts have perhaps prompted the Federal Commission for Migration Issues to inquire whether the database has had any bearing on the issuance of resident permits, as reported by the NZZ (citing an interview on Swiss Radio DRS).

The report is available in French here and in German here.